Find The Very Cheapest Car Insurance

We compare the prices, so you don't have to!!

Is third party car insurance the cheapest?


Conclusion: to find the cheapest cover, you need to check comprehensive prices, as well as third party fire and theft. Treat third party only with extreme caution!

Comparison of comprehensive and 3rd party prices


These are the results of a hundred car insurance price comparisons we made, for people with different ages, cars, addresses etc. We recorded the quotations for comprehensive, third party fire and theft (TPFT), and third party only cover. Where third party only cover was the cheapest option, the quote is highlighted in red, and the last column shows the potential savings between the price for comprehensive and TPFT cover. Where the TPFT policies are more expensive, this is shown as a negative figure.

Comprehensive 3rd party fire & theft Third party only Savings
622.65 620.73 620.73 1.92
1282.25 963.60 960.30 318.65
786.35 770.45 788.70 15.90
1481.70 1086.80 1080.20 394.90
831.95 831.95 872.30 0
3187.54 8169.70 8133.40 -4982.16
939.49 1310.10 1884.82 -370.61
342.12 342.12 370.09 0
1485.47 1510.90 4109.60 -25.43
508.75 435.11 767.80 73.64
429.44 339.62 504.87 89.82
916.62 964.04 964.04 -47.42
1468.37 1288.95 1421.88 179.42
508.87 620.73 620.73 -111.86
336.26 347.60 633.20 -11.34
806.30 808.50 807.40 -2.20
271.73 276.97 785.40 -5.24
367.84 306.78 433.48 61.06
679.77 636.45 636.45 43.32
343.32 347.18 692.14 -3.86
616.41 650.66 650.66 -34.25
1303.20 982.30 1303.20 320.90
786.35 625.91 1303.20 160.44
1613.39 1183.60 1561.96 429.89
502.25 831.95 883.95 -329.70
3604.87 7990.40 10833.90 -4385.53
342.12 342.12 342.12 0
476.70 416.90 729.77 59.80
374.37 298.29 430.33 76.08
835.47 1002.34 1002.34 -166.87
1398.50 1351.95 1421.88 46.55
516.65 636.06 636.06 -119.41
336.26 347.60 709.56 -11.34
834.90 808.50 1526.21 26.40
273.43 273.43 1417.62 0
502.25 469.73 735.45 32.52
843.21 698.94 728.77 144.27
343.32 347.18 490.56 -3.86
939.49 1139.60 1893.93 -200.11
1485.47 1524.21 1524.21 -38.74
502.25 487.30 735.45 14.95
637.75 636.06 636.06 1.69
1303.20 1285.90 1303.20 17.30
787.84 722.66 797.50 65.18
1644.50 1206.70 1452.00 437.80
1300.16 1177.00 1171.50 123.16
8354.50 8511.80 9999.00 -157.30
1274.90 1271.60 1745.08 3.30
373.75 386.32 386.32 -12.57
1524.21 1434.62 1524.21 89.59
460.86 386.07 646.80 74.79
442.76 471.16 648.71 -28.40
760.91 964.04 964.04 -203.13
1468.31 1288.81 1421.84 179.50
576.24 620.73 620.73 -44.49
467.78 412.10 620.73 55.68
834.90 815.10 814.00 19.80
297.93 301.22 795.30 -3.29
706.71 636.45 636.45 70.26
343.32 511.73 706.99 -168.41
622.65 636.41 636.41 -13.76
1303.20 963.12 1155.00 340.08
786.35 737.95 794.20 48.40
1613.43 1414.82 1443.20 198.61
1253.03 1196.80 1191.30 56.23
3659.63 8595.88 9284.00 -4936.25
939.49 1181.40 1175.90 -241.91
373.46 373.46 373.46 0
1524.21 1524.21 1524.21 0
488.80 434.11 792.00 54.69
374.37 298.29 430.33 76.08
917.08 1395.55 1395.55 -478.47
1401.00 1288.81 1421.84 112.19
516.65 621.81 621.81 -105.16
336.26 339.90 389.98 -3.64
702.60 818.40 817.30 -115.80
271.73 269.02 781.00 2.71
706.48 505.43 803.00 201.05
671.37 698.94 729.77 -27.57
343.32 341.18 401.63 2.14
1030.20 1023.00 1226.50 7.20
614.41 620.73 620.73 -6.32
786.35 770.45 785.40 15.90
1578.50 1206.70 1433.80 371.80
502.25 831.95 883.95 -329.70
3604.87 8430.40 10820.20 -4825.53
988.01 1157.20 1939.15 -169.19
355.52 355.52 355.52 0
1326.79 1524.21 1524.21 -197.42
476.70 416.90 729.77 59.80
374.37 298.29 430.33 76.08
916.62 964.04 964.04 -47.42
1448.50 1401.95 1421.99 46.55
516.65 620.73 620.73 -104.08
336.26 347.60 412.17 -11.34
808.50 811.80 810.70 -3.30
271.73 273.43 787.60 -1.70
502.25 469.73 659.77 32.52
706.71 636.45 636.45 70.26
343.21 347.18 501.40 -3.97




Home       Contact Us       Privacy Policy      Terms & Conditions

Copyright © 2016 Prudent Plus Ltd All Rights Reserved

verycheapestcarinsurance.org.uk is a trading style of Prudent Plus Ltd of Booths Hall, Booths Park, Chelford Road Knutsford WA16 8GS.
Our opening hours are: Monday to Thursday 9.00am to 6.00pm; Friday, 9.00am to 5.00pm; Saturday 9.00am to 12.30pm. Closed Sundays.

We do not give financial advice on this website. If in doubt get professional advice and always read the policy information before purchasing an insurance contract.

For regulatory reasons we have not named the price comparison sites that we have used, but all our data is available for inspection by any suitably qualified person or company who, in our opinion, has a good reason to see it. Our contact details are above.